Blog Archives

Lowry, Janice – Family Tales #5

Website

familytales51

Family Tales #5

This time around Janice only has one story to tell: her seeing Johnny Cash in 1958, when she was 12.  This comes up after she goes to see I Walked The Line, the Johnny Cash biopic from a few years ago.  I think I got the title right anyway, these things are occasionally hazy to me.  Anyway, she leaves the theater wondering why they didn’t show the part where he collapsed during his set, and goes on to tell the whole awkward tale of getting dragged there by an older sister and having to endure a blind date.  Did I mention she was 12?  It’s a great story, as they were right next to the stage and taking that whole scene in (as he was playing in a pretty seedy bar) from her childhood perspective is definitely a new take on the man.  The trouble is that the art seems more and more rushed to me.  She seems to nail it on certain panels and/or pages, but those backgrounds often just don’t look good.  I know, I’ve said many times that people should try to put some backgrounds in their panels just to flesh things out a bit, but it often looks like barely organized doodles in the background.  With storytelling this great and the concept of this being part of her journals of the last 30 years it’s still worth checking out, but I’m still not sold on the art.  Of course, it could be abstract art and I’m too stupid to notice, so be careful to pay too much attention to what I say here.

familytales52

Lowry, Janice – Family Tales #4

Website

Family Tales #4

Here I was, thinking I was at least vaguely qualified to opine on all these books due to the sheer volume of comics that I read, when I saw in the note attached with this comic (and #5, which should be up here shortly) that this is a graphic novel (spread apart, obviously) from the journals that she’s been keeping for 30 years… that have been accepted to the permanent collection of The Smithsonian Archives of American Art.  If you can ignore that horrendous run-on sentence, please note that I am out of my league here.  I am intrigued as to where this series started, as #4 picks up with the introduction of her journals, meaning #1-3 were about…?  Regardless, when I hear that somebody is starting a graphic novel based on 30 years of personal journals, that’s instantly fascinating.  This issue details a trip she took when she was 14, her memories of the trip and the way she described it in her journal.  She also talks about the concept of flashbulb memories, how her journals help her teach and how the telling of this story landed her in the hospital.  OK, there were other factors, but she still mostly blames the art.  The only trouble is with the art, as it occasionally looks sloppy and rushed.  Looking over her website I can see that she might have trouble sticking to depicting literal reality (I can relate), which is NOT something that has to be a detriment in the making of comics.  Either way it’s a minor quibble, and it’s not going to do a thing to dull my interest in the making of a graphic novel based on 30ish years of a life.  No price but this is nicely put together… $4?